To the Stars at first appears like a heartwarming film about two girls who discover their true selves. A symbol of hope for LGBTQ+ youth - the kind of film viewers turn to not only for entertainment, but to feel understood.
Its stereotypical portrayal of lesbian characters creates a backwards message that does not belong in 2021. Rather than inspiring its target audience, To the Stars' mishandled LGBTQ+ representation raises the question of how period cinema can instill hope in audiences today.
The two misfits find refuge in each other and gradually, Maggie helps Iris blossom into an independent, confident young woman. However, Maggie fails to achieve the same success. Behind her lies is the truth: that her father hits her, that she likes girls. Although she appears "normal," she feels far from it.
This ending portrays the two LGBTQ+ characters as stereotypes, not people. Members of the LGBTQ+ community have been stereotypically labeled as pedophiles; the liaison between the thirty-year-old woman and teenage girl is downright pedophilic, which only underscores that assumption.
Maggie's suicide at the end rehashes exclusionary narratives of the past. The ending of To the Stars echoes the tragic story arc prevalent in lesbian pulp fiction, a genre that gained traction in the 1950s. Although these novels overtly depicted relationships between women, publishers required them to end with characters "cutting their wrists, drowning themselves in a swimming pool, or... switching to heterosexuality,".
Like in the pulp fiction novels, Maggie's suicide implies that she has gone "to the stars" - that it's best ending for a lesbian girl.
To the Stars attempts to embrace acceptance, but its 20th-century mindset contradicts its flimsy 21st-century claim. The last shot depicts Iris and her new boyfriend kissing in the lake where Maggie drowned, a happily-ever-after ending for the straight girl but a morbid fate for the lesbian one.
In these films, the characters are able to rise above the limitations of their times, or at least stay true to their identities despite struggle. Faced with even greater societal barriers than those that exist today, they still overcome their obstacles. This kind of historical drama gives us hope. To the Stars does not.